I don’t normally write reviews for YA novels. I typically stick to reviewing Christian theology or discipleship books. However I do read a lot of YA fiction. In this case, I had to made an exception. The author is my friend and I wouldn’t be honest if I didn’t give her my opinion…for the whole world to see.
Having said that, Mindspeak, is not JUST a YA novel. It’s YA/Sci-Fi/Romance. Like I said, I read lots of YA fiction. I read my share of fantasy/sci-fi as well. But I don’t read romance. I read Twilight when it first came out to make sure it was appropriate for my then preteen daughter. I liked parts of it but the whole Team Edward/Team Jacob made me vomit in my mouth. So I skipped the movies.
I say that because it’s hard for me to write a review about a book where I am CLEARLY NOT part of the target audience. Some books can appeal to a larger audience while still being truly YA (Harry Potter). But I think that may be the exception rather than the rule, particularly in our modern day niche marketing/publishing industry.
If it sounds like I’m making excuses to avoid being critical of my friend’s book, well, you’re wrong. Heather Sunseri does a wonderful job of character AND plot development. Her characters are consistent, though mysterious. You can read plenty of other reviews to understand the plot, but it’s definitely unique; Heather’s no copycat.
USA Today wrote,
Mindspeak combines science, paranormal romance, and timely ethical debates within a compelling teen world… Romantic, mysterious, and exciting, Mindspeak by Heather Sunseri is a debut that delivers on every level.
I can’t argue with that! So while I won’t begin reading romance novels on a regular basis, I will pick up the next chapter in the Mindspeak saga simply because the ethical debate of cloning (from the perspective of a clone!) and Heather’s well-paced plot development left me with wanting more!
Louie Giglio is one of the best oral communicators I’ve ever heard. But can he translate some of the best sermons I’ve ever heard into great reading? Not great. Not bad either but mixed.
I agreed to review
Don’t read this book or any Leonard Sweet book if you’re comfortable with your theology and biblical understanding. Do read this book if you want to be challenged (within an orthodox context) about your understanding of some well-known biblical texts and theological concepts.
I hate to be the naysayer but I read so many books by pastors that look like sermons or sermon series simply made into a book. I’ve been tempted to do the same thing. And why not? Here’s why not? Sermons prepared to be preached don’t always translate well into books made to be read.
The first time I read
Gene Edwards’ book “Living Close to God…when you’re not good at it” is the perfect title for a book to hook people in who may be struggling with their day-to-day walk with God. I saw it and thought, “Exactly what I need to jump-start my one-on-one relationship with God.” The book promises that “you will find many practical helps, even if, like me, you are a Christian who is not endowed with a natural spiritual aptitude.” But for this reader, I didn’t find it true.
Larry Arnn’s The Founder’s Key, though at times difficult to read, is an excellent primer on the historical connection between The Declaration of Independence and the U.S. Constitution. This is necessary because of attacks on the primacy of the Constitution by those who would wish certain elements of it away by calling on the spirit of the Declaration.